Disabled student's parents taken to court for school absences

Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 6/24/2010 6:22 am
San Antonio --  His parents say he was sick. But the school district says he was truant. Now it's taking the family of a disabled child to court.

8-year-old Austin Besterman has a lot of physical disabilities. Still, he loves drumming, singing, and going to school. Problem is, when he's sick those things aren't always possible.

News 4 WOAI Reporter Mireya Villarreal visited Austin Besterman on a good day. It was a healthy day free of headaches, nausea, and exhaustion. But it isn't always like that for Austin.

"I actually have three illnesses,” Austin explained. “Arnold-Chiari Malformation, Spina Bifida, and Hydrocephalus.”

They all take their toll on his little body.

"He has a hard time toileting. He has a hard time getting dressed,” his father, William Besterman, told us. “And he has to have his braces and crutches to walk."

This past year Austin had a major battle with his Hydrocephalus. The illness causes too much fluid to be produced in a person's head, affecting the brain. Austin missed 32 days of school this year because of it.

"When he had a headache we would keep him home so we could monitor him because if things started to get really bad, which is what we were told could happen. Then we would immediately take him to the emergency room," William Besterman said.

Austin was only excused for 20 of those 32 absences. The district considered the rest of the days as skipping.

"We've outreached to this family on multiple occasions. We met with them on February 27 and laid out a plan for them,” Pascual Gonzalez, Northside ISD spokesperson, pointed out. “Unfortunately they didn't follow through."

Austin's mom and dad were taken to court and charged with “parent contributing to non-attendance”.

"We had notes. Every time we had to keep him home for anything,” William told us. “Every time we took him to the doctor's office we provided notes."

"We do not have sufficient documentation from the parents or the doctor that indicates that this child has this health issue," Pascual Gonzalez refuted.

Justice of the Peace Stephen Walker handles truancy cases in town. While he's not the judge in Austin's case, he tells News 4 WOAI over the last year he's seen a rise in cases just like it; mentally and physically disabled students and their parents being taken to court.

"I don't want to see special needs kids falling through the cracks. They don't belong in the justice of the peace courts," Justice of the Peace Stephen Walker said.

Judge Walker is meeting with San Antonio Legal Aid lawyers to see how they can keep cases like this out of the courtroom. He's also contacting school district officials.

"I'm asking the school district's to fix it,” he told us. “You're not doing what's right for the child."

Northside's spokesperson also explained they have thousands of other mentally or physically disabled student's whose parents follow their attendance guidelines. And they don't often have problems like this.

Justice of the peace walker said while they have seen a rise in cases like Austin's, they don't typically have a problem with Northside ISD.

Austin is still being moved to the next grade. His absences won't hold him back. But his parents have pled not guilty to the charges. Their hearing is in September.



Share
45 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of News 4 WOAI (WOAI.com)

roll22 - 7/1/2010 10:52 AM
People, this a disable child with health issues. There's no place for this in the court rooms. NISD needs to be more understanding and find other solutions. What kind of people run NISD?

JaneQDoe66 - 6/29/2010 8:49 AM
I think NISD still has it's homebound program. The quadripalegic student at Stevens was using it. May NISD should have offered it to the family first before taking them to court. It's strange...NISD enforces this more at the elementary level than middle or high school. High school students get to go to "Attendance Recovery".

mother1st - 6/28/2010 9:12 PM
Absolutely ridiculous! A waste of the taxpayer's money and the court's time. The most tragic is the money these parents are having to pay to be represented in court that could be used to help with their undoubted extreme expenses. Just another of Northside School District's poor judgement. I would suggest the family contact the Homebound program and request "intermittment homebound" unless NS in its "wisdom" has discontinued this vital part of the program. It serves children like ours perfectly AND they get their funds.

IRUN2 - 6/28/2010 4:58 PM
fight, fight, with all your might, cause we all know that this ain't right, hopefully in the end your family well see some light, parents are slowly losing their rights as parents nowadays, for times have surely changed.

mbesterman - 6/28/2010 2:22 PM
Tardies are Unexcused in Austin's school, as well.

IRUN2 - 6/28/2010 10:27 AM
yea the problem in school districts records keeping is a huge mess, over crowdedness contributes to a lot of this, some school districts even have school students handling input info, while staffers are kicking back in their chairs, way to common of a problem, i see this in my school district, if a student goes in late to class they automatically mark him or her as absent for the whole day.

JaneQDoe66 - 6/28/2010 8:30 AM
I have a disability and sometimes the medication makes it hard for me to get up in the morning. Especially when its a new medication. When my child was in elementary school in NISD I was taken to court because of her tardies. I explained it to the principal but she didn't care. She kept saying it's the law. I ended up taking a plea agreement and paying a fine because I was nerovous and didn't know any better. What I found out later was that they went by what the teacher had written down and it was not the same as what the attendance office recorded. I took it to the superintendent and she looked over everything and apologized. She said their records were all over the place and I should have never been taken to court but since I already took a plea there was nothing she could do. I immediately withdrew my child and started home schooling her! NISD schools do not apply this across the board. Only certain schools.

proudnative - 6/26/2010 8:31 PM
If Austin truly is too sick to be in school, then document it or move him to the Reddix center. There ARE options. In the meantime, please know that it is the STATE and FEDERAL regulations that require children to be in school. School districts do NOT make up the rules to suit themselves and they MUST enforce them according to the LAW. Please place blame where it belongs .... that would be with the legislatures that make the truancy laws and NOT the districts that MUST follow them.

freeman - 6/26/2010 4:53 PM
This is the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard of in my life. I too have children in NISD, and I make sure they are in school, EVERYDAY, unless they are sick or have a medical or dental appointment. Although a child is sick, a doctor's appointment is not always necessary, and a Dr's note is not available. Whether a child has special needs or not, NISD REALLY needs to back off a little. This is a wonderful district; however some of their policies are a little beyond comprehension, and their priorties are way off. They need to focus more on the strange "Wolflike" behavior which is haunting our hallways, and leave the physically sick children alone.

skmdn - 6/26/2010 3:48 AM
home schooling does not provide the wonderful socialization needs for these students. This is often the only chance they have to interact with others--they don't have soccer, neighbors, lessons, etc. Also home cannot offer specialized equipment like lifts or vestibular boards, gait trainers, computer programs, PT, OT, ST, vision support, supervised outings, counselors, special Olympics, and fun! Assistive technology devices at school are essential for those with limited physical capabilities, and are mostly not available at home. Also, homebound teachers aren't approved unless a doctor states the student will be unable to attend for at least three weeks (this may not be exactly the rule, but you get the idea), and then it takes awhile to start. How do you know how long they will be sick? And if not well, home school is still often too demanding.
Contact the Trouble Shooters
Have something for the News 4 WOAI Troubleshooters? Call them at 210.476.1070 and leave a message. Or e-mail them at TroubleShooters@woaitv.com.

If you want to report a health issue at a restaurant, call the City of San Antonio at 210-207-8853.

Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.