CPS Energy policy costs military mom big money

(News 4 WOAI)
(News 4 WOAI)
Reported by: Jaie Avila
Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 9/16/2010 11:33 am

SAN ANTONIO -- You might think not receiving your monthly CPS Energy bill would be reason to celebrate. But it could mean something's wrong.

The utility's policy is to stop sending you bills when they detect a big increase in usage.

As News 4 WOAI Trouble Shooter Jaie Avila reports, that policy has left one military mom with a huge power bill right as she's about to deploy.

It's the way most of us discover our home is using too much power, or an appliance is malfunctioning: we notice it on our bill. Michelle Carter says it makes no sense for CPS Energy to stop sending it to you. Michelle says she had no idea her air conditioner was suddenly using four times as much energy.

"My husband is deployed to Iraq, I have a two year old son, and in three weeks I deploy myself for the next two and a half months", she told us.

Michelle says this is the worst possible time for her to get a close to $1,900 electric bill.

Sometime in July, Michelle's air conditioning and heating unit malfunctioned, and they both began running at the same time. Her house was still cool, but the air conditioner was using tremendous amounts of power to compensate for the heater.

"Nothing in my house lent itself to think I had a problem, the only way I would have known was through that electric bill."

But when CPS Energy detected a spike in her usage, it didn't send her a bill for July, or any kind of notice that something was wrong. Michelle conscientiously called CPS, even estimated her July payment and sent it in, but customer service wouldn't give her any information about her account.

"They didn't tell me that my energy consumption had quadrupled. They didn't give me an opportunity to investigate on my end. Meanwhile, my bill continued to quadruple for two and a half months straight", she complained.

Finally, on September 1st, she received a huge bill for almost $1,900. CPS told her it took all that time to investigate and determine that it's meter was not to blame for the increase, and for the first time, informed Michelle she might want to check her appliances.

The very next day Michelle had the air conditioner problem fixed, and she says it would have been done two months ago, if CPS Energy had just sent her a bill.

She added, "You look at the bill you see the charts, I mean, it's quadrupled even on the charts! I would have called CPS and said, 'Why is my bill like this?'"

For two days we tried to get an interview with the Director of Customer Service for CPS Energy, Sandra Nobile Currans.  We even went down to CPS Energy headquarters in person, but we were told she was busy in meetings.

CPS Energy did send us a statement though, saying:

"We will continue to further investigate this case, in an attempt to arrive at a reasonable resolution."

But the utility says it won't be changing its policy about not sending out bills. Even if it leaves some customers in the dark about problems.

A CPS Energy spokesman says if you don't get a monthly bill, call them immediately to see if they are investigating a change in energy consumption.

But since the woman in our story couldn't get much information that way, you may also want to have an electrician check your appliances, just in case.

Share
55 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of News 4 WOAI (WOAI.com)

JimmyCrackhorn - 9/17/2010 5:41 PM
4 Votes
An A/C unit running 24/7 is NOT going to cost $900 this is silly. But I will say this much for CPS...their billing system and online portal are THE WORST customer service efforts I have ever seen for a multi billion dollar corporation. We have a monopoly so they can do whatever they want, if I had a choice I would MAKE ONE!!

phenry64 - 9/17/2010 12:45 PM
1 Vote
To get a 1900 bill, it has to be going on for quite some time for one. Normally, I would be bashing the CITY for needing revenues to fund their NEEDLESS 2% COLA when they are in the middle of a recession and when the CPI is moving by ZERO -- but in this case, I have to say lack of periodic maintenance is the problem here. Need to spend the $150 a year on the service contract....you skip it....this can happen!

COMMONSENSE101 - 9/17/2010 12:33 PM
1 Vote
I think that if CPS is not going to send you a bill, at least send you a letter that there has been an excessive usage of electricity and that they are doing an internal investigation and quite possibly , you many have appliances inspected to help with an investigation. NOt notifying a customer is absolutely immoral.

LisaPowers - 9/17/2010 11:45 AM
2 Votes
RickTammy, it doesn't say that the only called once, just that she called - but we don't know how many times. Besides, it's not like everyone has the time to wait on hold with CPS every single day! She was more proactive than most people would have been, and she's still getting screwed over.

nursshar1 - 9/17/2010 10:45 AM
0 Votes
Baven, you are right - she consumed the energy and should pay. That is NOT the point. The POINT is, if they had sent a bill, monthly, as expected, she would have seen the consumption much sooner and been tipped off there was a problem. She could have had her problem fixed by then, saving her at LEAST half of the money she has to pay, as well as the wasted energy. It makes more sense for them to stop sending a bill oif consumption goes way DOWN, and I wonder if that is what the policy was supposed to be and when it was drafted the words got switched. Turnover of staff can be high enough that they just follow what they read. What a shame that would be right?

velae956 - 9/17/2010 9:47 AM
0 Votes
Found myself in a some what similar situation. Moved to Mascoutah, Illinois (military, Scott AFB)and when I was looking for houses I was worried about the taxes more than worrying about utilities but did I pay the price! My first water bill was $920 freaking dollars. I thought I had done all my research and looked into their utilities section and nowhere does it tell you that they charge the same amount of water consumption as the sewer. I know I have to pay for sewer but come on these people should have some common sense that not all the water is being used inside. But I guess some of these companies use these strategies to rip us off. Because after the fact they told me to buy a Deduct meter that meters the amount of water being wasted outside. Either way I know for a fact that I didn't waste 63,000 gallons of damn water but I had no proof of showing that because when we moved in I didn't check the meter reading. So I basically got screwed. Leason learned for the next time.

papichulolove - 9/17/2010 9:25 AM
3 Votes
Look, at no time is the blame on the consumer. We are forced to use this monopolistic utility company, only to NOT GET A BILL WHEN USAGE GOES UP?? That makes NO sense whatsoever, and we ALL know its about CPS making money. Plain and Simple. We customers deserve monthly bill, regardless of USAGE! WE CUSTOMERS DEMAND CPS IMMEDIATELEY END THAT POLICY AND SEND MONTHLY BILLS OUT IN A CONSISTENT MANNER!!! Ms. Carter, thank you for you and your husbands service to our country. As a Veteratn myself, I am extremely upset at how you have been treated.

europdude - 9/17/2010 8:38 AM
1 Vote
Almost everyday I have problems with power surges, this affect my AC, PC, refrigerator, tv's popping off etc ... are they doing that to raise the bill ?I hope CPS executives reading all of this comments... the truth hurts ...

Baven - 9/16/2010 11:33 PM
2 Votes
I don't like CPS, especially due to their free-money rebate giveaways. That being said, her equipment malfunctioned and she used what she was billed. Other ratepayers don't owe her a nickel. If she's driving on a flat tire, does she go blame the gas station for telling her she's filling up the car too much?

uknown123 - 9/16/2010 10:14 PM
0 Votes
Gosh....that's so expensive. where's she gonna get the money from???
Contact the Trouble Shooters
Have something for the News 4 WOAI Troubleshooters? Call them at 210.476.1070 and leave a message. Or e-mail them at TroubleShooters@woaitv.com.

If you want to report a health issue at a restaurant, call the City of San Antonio at 210-207-8853.

Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.