Collister Investigates

"We will fix this" promises CPS Board Chairman

Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 2/08/2012 2:59 pm
“We will fix this.”

That's the promise today from Derrick Howard, Chairman of the CPS Energy Board of Trustees.

It comes in response to my series of investigations revealing the inside story on how the publicly funded utility uses some of your money on expensive meals. Over the past two days I've reported on expensive meals, retirement parties and employee parties at CPS Energy that you paid for. Since then ratepayers have been emailing, calling and posting on our website, wanting to know how to stop CPS from misspending their money.

Throughout my investigation, the utility and CEO Doyle Beneby has justified the expenses. So it's unclear if the utility's top executive was just giving me lip service when he said, “There could be some areas where what you might have uncovered causes us to go back and look at our policy and and we'd be more than happy to do so.”

To make sure ratepayers get some kind of action, I went to Beneby's boss - Chairman Howard - who also has attended some of the events.

I asked him, “What do you say to those ratepayers who don't like the way this money is being spent?”

“At the end of the day, in my opinion, a lot of expenses can be challenged. I think there is always an opportunity to go back and review, retool and rethink what's appropriate and what's not -- and we'll do that," said Howard. "But I think the ratepayers can be assured that we continue to be and operate as one of the best utilities in the country.”

During a follow up phone call today, Howard told me CPS plans to review the expenses and its policies and in his words – “we will fix this.”

The latest embarrassing receipts I uncovered have to do with the former leader of the utility. When former CEO Milton Lee retired in 2010, it was a long goodbye that included not one - but four going away parties. Including meals at Bohanan’s restaurant for $3,174 with his senior management team. A trip to Fleming's steak house with board members for $2,120. And another dinner at Bohanan’s -- this time with his chiefs of staff for $1,106.

CPS says it cannot find the receipts from these meals, so we don't know exactly what you paid for.

Lee's farewell also included a lunch at La Villita for rank and file employees to say their goodbyes. The bill shows the event cost $6,182 and included $675 for balloon arches. Total tab to ratepayers for the long goodbye - $12,583.

These expenses and others I uncovered showing expensive wining and dining have ticked off a lot of ratepayers.

George Rodriguez is a self proclaimed taxpayer watchdog with the San Antonio Tea Party.

“Oh my gosh! A seven thousand dollar going away party?” asked Rodriguez.

“They may be talking about clean energy. The only thing getting cleaned here is our pocket books,” said Rodriguez, who is demanding CPS pull the plug on these pricey events. “We've got to remind them that people scrimp and save pennies to pay their bills, their electrical and gas bills. And for them to be squandering them in this manner just cannot be justified. I'm sorry, you just cannot tell us that this is okay.”

I'll be following up on this story to keep the heat on CPS Energy to make sure it spends your money more wisely.

Interview with CPS Energy attorney Carolyn Shellman

Share
56 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of News 4 WOAI (WOAI.com)

Jackieboy - 2/24/2012 10:49 PM
0 Votes
If the Mayor and City Council had any real interest in doing what they were elected for they would go over to CPS and Clean House. These people are not spending the Ratepayers money in a proper and legal way. Next thing they will want a rate increase!

nescio - 2/15/2012 9:09 PM
0 Votes
Juana Masa you are missing the point...this is big ....its $800,000 big. The only celebration I want from my utilities is a Black and white insert telling me that cps rates are the absolute lowest in Texas. Juana Masa, you sound like Trish deberry Guerra. Cps could really use a crisis consultant for a fat fee of course.

nescio - 2/15/2012 8:49 PM
0 Votes
That money needs to be returned...plain and simple. None of it can be justified. It is theft of taxpayer money.

wdoug62 - 2/10/2012 7:23 PM
0 Votes
There is no excuse for a utility to be hosting lavish parties and dinners for its elitist leadership, period. There is no justifiable reason to spend ratepayer funds for "Morale" either. The Mayor sits on that board and probably has attended some of those parties. He exhibits an objection to the expense only after the negative publicity as a result of this investigation. Hopefully a closer look at the lavish spending by the City Council, SAWS and VIA will come under scrutiny as well. All of them are doing this. In the case of CPS, this has been going on for many, many years. I wonder how much the fee was for just the interview with the attorney. And the band plays on.

esmiranda - 2/9/2012 4:14 PM
1 Vote
They should have their parties at McDonald's

upyours808 - 2/9/2012 10:31 AM
0 Votes
SOUNDS like Jane Doe be doing allot of work on her knees at the utility company. Blinded by IGNORANCE.

Concerned - 2/9/2012 8:57 AM
1 Vote
All the "fat cats" at CPS need to be investigated and ultimately fired. The only reason the comment from Howard "we will fix this" is relevant is because they were caught! How can we taxpayers have continued faith in our City leadership when such egregious activities like what has been reported have been occurring? This is only the tip of the cesspool!

cosmo511 - 2/8/2012 7:44 PM
1 Vote
@janeDoe I don't believe anyone is complaining about feeding crews working overtime to repair things in an emergency, like storms, or hurricanes. What do they get, a sandwich, whataburger if they are lucky. Its when this jerk Beneby, after making $590,000 dollars in wages and bonuses, invites his old chums in the guise of improving education at CPS thats chapping every ones ass. Did we also pay for their flight, hotel room? And at several hundred dollars, that was no meal at whatabuger. Oh sorry they don't serve wine at whataburger.

slickwilly - 2/8/2012 4:36 PM
2 Votes
How about a 'claw-back' rule? If the executives think it is justified, let them defend it in court or before a city elected board... and have to use their large salaries (400k plus huge bonuses and perks for Beneby I believe) to pay the taxpayers back. Bet they get real cheap when it is their own money on the line.

JKBLOPE - 2/8/2012 3:32 PM
2 Votes
@JaneDoe and other CPS management.Jane they're not going to read your comments and give you a raise. That's way to much spending for dinners and private parties. And Yes I do work for the utility sector. We are doing are job, nothing special.It rains, its cold and sometimes..Ice. I dont expect dinner. The job discription listed all these conditions, I still applied. Sure my job might make me superman in your eyes and a 6yr old's. Your job of loading the copier at CPS sounds cool to me. CPS managent needs to answer to public for these parties.
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.