Collister Investigates

Brian Collister's Blog: TXDOT fought release of crash data

Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 3/11/2010 5:32 pm
Alright, I admit it.

I talk on my cell phone when behind the wheel.

And apparently I'm not the only one. Last week I reported that San Antonio drivers are tops in the state in causing accidents while using their cell phones.

This revelation came after we obtained and analyzed a database of all vehicle crashes maintained by the Texas Department of Transportation. It revealed that since 2005 officers statewide have cited cell phone use as a contributing factor in more than 17,519 accidents, with 7,519 injuries and 167 deaths. What's worse - San Antonio tops the state with 1,611 crashes over that same period.

So why did The Texas Department of Transportation try to keep this information secret?

Here's what I mean by that - TXDOT officials fought tooth and nail to prevent the Crash Records Information System (CRIS) database from ever being released.

My fight to get these records started back in 2008 when I filed an open records request for the entire database. The Attorney General ruled it was public, but TXDOT challenged the ruling in court. It feared the ruling would mean that ambulance chasing attorneys and chiropractors would have access to the names and address of crash victims. (Ironically, they already get that information from our local police departments.)

To calm those concerns, our attorney reached a deal with TXDOT. The state would provide the data without any personal information and we would withdraw our request. But for some reason, the agency at the time was slow to finalize the deal... the reason now is clear.

This is when TXDOT decided to get sneaky.

Late one Friday afternoon last March, while the lawsuit was still going on, I stumbled across a bill filed in the legislature that would make the entire crash database secret!

It turns out that TXDOT officials had quietly gone to Senator John Carona of Dallas, the head of the Senate's Committee on Transportation and Homeland Security, and begged him to file a bill to ban release of the data - forever. The TXDOT officials decried the AG ruling and claimed it would spell disaster for accident victims who will be further besieged by rogue lawyers and doctors.

But TXDOT conveniently forgot to tell the senator about our lawsuit and the compromise it had agreed to. It also conveniently forgot to tell our lawyer that they had gone behind our back in a shameful attempt to shut off the data with a new law.

Once we learned what was going on, we sprung into action. I testified to the senate committee along with representatives of several open government and media groups. Luckily, the lawmakers listened and the governor eventually signed a bill making the data public - minus the personal information.

So why would TXDOT fight so hard to try and keep this information from you?
I don't know and could never get an honest answer from anyone at TXDOT.

If you ask anyone at the agency that was involved in this ridiculous attempt to seal off vital public information, they'll probably claim that I'm making all this up and the agency was only trying to protect poor accident victims.

And if you believe that, TXDOT will also sell you some toll roads if you're willing to buy that too.


Express News investigative reporter John Tedesco just wrote a great blog about about our fight with TXDOT - you can check it out by going to www.johntedesco.net
Share
13 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of News 4 WOAI (WOAI.com)

silencedobad - 3/17/2010 12:46 AM
During the congressional hearings involving Toyota, Sec. of Trans. LaHood vowed over and over again that he's got cell phone users in the cross hairs. Idk, but could it be that the state may have attempted to protect Texas residents from a potential and future onslaught by the U.S. Transportation Dept.? Logically, if Texas ranks 1st in this type of accident, wouldn't it be Texas who would incur the most lost federal dollars in light of the fact that Texas would rather not yield to additional federal regulation? If Ray LaHood is a man of his word, Texas residents are about to get spanked!

buddyw - 3/16/2010 1:18 PM
Brian, I tip my hat off to you for a job well done!! Keep up the good work San Antonio 1s lucky to have you! We have got to remember TXDOT next time we vote!--Buddy Wells

txmike64a - 3/14/2010 8:55 AM
This is about government employees protecting their positions. I have no respect for government behaving badly. I guess they're feeling emboldened with communism nearly at our doorstep and political party doesn't matter here, it's a ruling class protecting its position. Government people violating public trust need to be breaking rocks into smaller rocks. I've always said, 1. uphold the law, 2. behave in an honest manner, 3. take care of your own problems -- if we do these three things, then the spirit of the Republic of Texas will live on. If we don't, then we slide into a communist hell.

Kareni - 3/13/2010 7:52 PM
Thus another label comes unglued. Stay tuned; this kid has talent. About two dozen trade publicly. The hatch in the brain slammed. Everybody will feather his nest. He is also a very tough customer. You can hear them in the movies. Living with that was really scary. But Brian knows, and don't you forget it. He's looking for the problems, and will shine a bright light into the caverns of secrets to bring out the dead into the light. That is his job, and he's good at it. Look out, thieves, liars, and whores. Brian is looking for you.

Higgs Boson - 3/12/2010 8:49 PM
All the composer asks is a willing ear. We need skills here. If that is not enough to entice businesses to get on board, maybe another kind of pressure will. This behavior is the result of an insensitive, poorly trained police force. The first maze was the human body. The second amazing thing Brian Collister has done, besides winning at least two Emmy awards, is to perform his work in San Antonio. This is a product of extreme insight. His courage alone could cause false walls to collapse, and in fact certain departments of the Texas government are working now to determine whether or not he caused that retaining wall to fall apart. So far all the state knows is that he has a special friend in the construction department, someone in the family.

Wonder - 3/12/2010 2:24 PM
good stuff brian. i cant think of why they'd try so hard to withhold that data either

judley1269 - 3/12/2010 12:35 PM
Perhaps their real reason for keeping it secret is so they can sell the information to their lawyer buddies.

Peanut - 3/12/2010 11:06 AM
P.P.S. While we're at it, look at your phone bills and add up those ghost anonymous fees all over the bill which add up to from $19 to $24 ~ for agencies we've never heard of or know the 'purpose' of the agencies. MORE THIEVES. GHOST thieves. Thought our 'government' was to "return" those bogus fees. Seen any cash, folks?

Kenoscope - 3/12/2010 11:04 AM
All records are public.... Until someone asks to see them.

Peanut - 3/12/2010 11:02 AM
Well, well ~ imagine that! ANOTHER Government Entity screwing us? Naw ~ never happen! DUH ~ DO THEY THINK WE DON'T K N O W THEY STAB US EACH AND EVERY DAY? Psst....All levels of government ~ WE ARE ON TO YOU....GET IT? THIEVES.
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.